More than two decades after the devastating 9/11 attacks, the aftermath continues to impact lives, with a growing number of individuals diagnosed with related illnesses. The World Trade Center Health Program, established in 2011, stands as a crucial resource, providing treatment for a range of conditions, including cancer, asthma, and PTSD. However, recent federal staffing cuts have cast a shadow of uncertainty over the program’s future, threatening the health and well-being of thousands who rely on its services.
This article delves into the challenges facing the 9/11 health program, exploring the impact of staffing reductions on enrollment, treatment access, and the overall ability to serve those affected by the attacks. We’ll examine the perspectives of lawyers, advocates, and program members, highlighting the potential consequences of these cuts and the ongoing efforts to ensure the program’s long-term sustainability.
The Ever-Growing Need for 9/11 Health Support
The repercussions of the 9/11 attacks extend far beyond the immediate tragedy. The toxic dust and debris that blanketed lower Manhattan have led to a surge in 9/11-related illnesses. As of December, approximately 132,000 individuals have enrolled in the World Trade Center Health Program, with a staggering 64% diagnosed with at least one linked condition. Cancer remains the most prevalent, affecting over 40,000 members. People join the program for various reasons, some seeking treatment after developing illnesses, while others participate in annual screenings for early detection.
Todd Cleckley, a nurse medical specialist at Barasch & McGarry, a law firm representing 9/11 responders and survivors, emphasizes the potential dangers of the staffing cuts.
“These cuts are going to potentially delay treatment, delay diagnosis and early detection of their cancers, and it’s going to cost lives,”
he warns.
“The health program already operated on a very slim staffing margin. We’re only beginning to see what those negative impacts will be.”
The Impact of Federal Staffing Cuts
The World Trade Center Health Program has faced a tumultuous period, marked by a series of staffing changes. Sixteen staffers were initially affected by the Trump administration’s actions in February, only to be reinstated following public outcry. However, in late March, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced further layoffs, impacting 16 staffers at the program and its director. While the director was later reinstated, the other staffers remain without their positions.
These cuts extend beyond the World Trade Center Health Program, impacting the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), the agency responsible for overseeing the program. Benjamin Chevat, executive director of 9/11 Health Watch, explains that the layoffs have affected employees who certify the eligibility of patients’ 9/11-related illnesses for federal funding, despite not being on the program’s direct payroll.
“They weren’t on the World Trade Center Program payroll, but they did things that are essential to the program running,”
Chevat said.
Delays in Enrollment and Treatment
The staffing cuts have already begun to impact the program’s operations. Advocates report that enrollment has effectively halted since April 1, with no new members being accepted. This delay in enrollment and certification can have dire consequences, as Michael Barasch, a partner at Barasch & McGarry, points out.
“You’ll never hear me say something inflammatory just to make a headline, but it is a fact: People will die because of these decisions,”
Barasch said.
The delays can lead to delayed diagnoses and treatment, potentially impacting the effectiveness of interventions, especially for time-sensitive conditions like cancer. For current members, the program provides annual screenings at certified health clinics, where doctors assess individuals for conditions linked to 9/11. However, with certifications stalled, patients may face uncertainty about their ability to access the necessary treatment at no cost.
Community Advocacy and Political Action
In response to the staffing cuts, lawyers and advocates are actively engaging with lawmakers to advocate for the reinstatement of the affected staffers. New York City Mayor Eric Adams has expressed his office’s commitment to restoring essential resources and ensuring quality healthcare for 9/11 responders and survivors.
Beyond the immediate staffing crisis, the World Trade Center Health Program faces long-term budgetary challenges. Despite the program’s expiration date set for 2090, looming budget shortfalls could force limitations on new enrollments and benefit reductions for current members starting in October 2028. A bipartisan bill has been proposed to address this funding gap, and advocates are urging legislators to support its passage.
The Human Cost: Personal Stories of Impact
The statistics surrounding the 9/11 health crisis can feel overwhelming, but it’s crucial to remember the individuals behind the numbers. Michael O’Connell, a former firefighter who assisted with search-and-rescue operations after 9/11, was diagnosed with a rare inflammatory disease linked to his exposure. He credits the World Trade Center Health Program for helping him manage his symptoms. The possibility of new members being unable to enroll or receive treatment is “deeply disturbing” to O’Connell.
Mariama James, a lower Manhattan resident who was pregnant during 9/11, is awaiting approval for a treatment for her sleep apnea through the program. The uncertainty surrounding the staffing cuts has left her concerned about the potential delays.
“How are they going to get a new medication covered if the doctors from NIOSH have been fired?” James said. “I’ll be waiting forever for that medication.”
These personal stories underscore the real-world consequences of the challenges facing the 9/11 health program.
Securing the Future of 9/11 Health Support
The federal staffing cuts impacting the World Trade Center Health Program pose a significant threat to the health and well-being of thousands of individuals affected by the 9/11 attacks. These cuts have the potential to delay enrollment, impede access to treatment, and ultimately jeopardize the lives of those who rely on the program’s services. The situation demands immediate attention and decisive action.
Lawmakers must prioritize the reinstatement of the affected staffers and address the long-term budgetary challenges facing the program. The 9/11 community deserves unwavering support, and it is our collective responsibility to ensure the program’s sustainability, honoring the sacrifices made by responders and survivors and safeguarding their health for years to come.
Leave a Reply