New data reveals a concerning trend: New York City students are significantly underperforming on the SAT compared to their peers across the state and nation. This exclusive report by FYM News highlights the troubling decline in scores, particularly in mathematics, raising critical questions about the readiness of NYC students for college and future success. These results, the lowest in at least seven years, prompt urgent calls for improved instruction and resource allocation within the city’s public school system.
The implications of these low SAT scores extend beyond college admissions. Standardized tests like the SAT are often viewed as indicators of broader educational quality and can influence perceptions of a city’s ability to prepare its young people for the challenges of a competitive global landscape. The disparities in scores among different demographic groups within NYC also underscore persistent inequities in access to quality education and resources.
This article will delve into the specifics of the latest SAT results, examining the score gaps between NYC students and their state and national counterparts. We’ll explore the potential factors contributing to this decline, including the ongoing impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic and socioeconomic disparities, and we’ll hear from education experts and community leaders about the steps needed to reverse this alarming trend and ensure a brighter future for all NYC students.
NYC SAT Scores: A Troubling Decline
The latest data paints a stark picture of academic performance in New York City public schools. In 2024, NYC students averaged a mere 473 on the math portion of the SAT, a staggering 71 points below the New York state average and 32 points lower than the national average. This significant underperformance places NYC students at a considerable disadvantage when applying to colleges and universities across the country.
Reading and writing scores, while not declining as sharply as math, also reveal a concerning gap. NYC students averaged 482 in reading and writing, matching the 2023 results. However, this score still falls significantly short of the state average of 553 and the national average of 519. These numbers collectively represent the lowest average SAT scores for NYC students in at least seven years, signaling a persistent and worsening challenge for the city’s education system.
This overall decline follows a concerning trend that began in 2022. The city Department of Education’s Friday release of the data further confirmed this downward spiral, making it imperative to examine the root causes and implement immediate corrective measures. “It’s another wake up call for New York City Public Schools to concentrate on improved instruction in core subjects,” remarked David Bloomfield, an educator professor at Brooklyn College and the CUNY Graduate Center.
Significant Score Gaps Among Racial Groups
Beyond the overall decline, the data exposes significant disparities in SAT scores among different racial and ethnic groups within New York City. Asian students achieved an average of 582 on the math portion, while white students averaged 536. In stark contrast, Hispanic students scored an average of 430, and Black students averaged a dismal 426. These numbers highlight a troubling inequity in the city’s education system, with minority students consistently lagging behind their white and Asian counterparts.
These gaps aren’t just numbers; they represent real-world barriers to opportunity for countless students. Bloomfield, the Brooklyn College professor, noted being “shocked by an especially wide gap between Asian and white test takers compared to Black and Hispanics.” The numbers reveal that Hispanic students scored more than 100 points less than their white counterparts, while Black students were 118 points lower than the rest of the state’s average. These disparities contribute to a cycle of inequality, limiting college choices and future career prospects for many minority students.
While Asian students in NYC demonstrated an improvement in reading and writing compared to the previous year, white students experienced a decline. Black students’ reading and writing averages saw a slight increase, while Hispanic students’ averages dipped. These mixed results underscore the complex and multifaceted nature of the challenges facing NYC’s education system, requiring targeted interventions to address the unique needs of each demographic group.
Potential Causes: COVID-19, Socioeconomic Disadvantage, and Test-Optional Policies
Several factors may be contributing to the alarming decline in NYC SAT scores. The ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly the disruption of in-person learning and the challenges of remote instruction, likely played a significant role. Many students experienced learning loss during this period, especially those from low-income families who lacked access to adequate technology and resources.
Socioeconomic disparities also contribute significantly to the score gaps. As Eric Nadelstern, former deputy chancellor for instruction at the DOE, pointed out, “The population of students in New York City compared to the rest of the state, compared to the rest of the country, is poorer and has more kids of color, more special ed kids and more immigrants who whose native language is other than English.” These factors create systemic disadvantages that hinder academic achievement.
Additionally, the rise of test-optional policies at many colleges and universities may have disincentivized some students from taking the SAT, or from preparing as diligently as they might have in the past. As DOE spokeswoman Jenna Lyle stated, “In line with national trends, we’ve seen SAT scores dip as more students opt to not retake the test, likely due to increased SAT-optional policies at colleges across the country.” This shift could be contributing to a decline in the overall performance of students taking the exam.
Calls for Action: Academic Support and Targeted Interventions
Education experts and community leaders are calling for immediate action to address the declining SAT scores and reverse the alarming trend. Frances Kweller, director of the Manhattan- and Queens-based tutoring company Kweller Prep, emphasized the need to “keep expanding access to academic support — especially for students who haven’t traditionally had it.” Targeted tutoring programs, test preparation workshops, and additional resources are crucial to ensuring that all students have the opportunity to succeed.
There needs to be a refocused commitment to the core subjects, which students will need to succeed in college and beyond. David Bloomfield advocates for New York City Public Schools to “concentrate on improved instruction in core subjects.” Concentrating on the fundamentals of reading, writing, and math and improving student engagement in these areas will lead to greater success.
Avish Jain, a Brooklyn Tech 11th-grader, hopes that his SAT score will help him get into college on scholarship. To that end, he expressed his frustration with the current climate, saying, “I wish more support was available in schools.” Providing more comprehensive support systems within schools, including guidance counseling, mentorship programs, and access to technology, is essential to leveling the playing field for all students.
Advanced Placement Success: A Glimmer of Hope
Despite the concerning SAT results, there are some positive developments within the NYC education system. DOE spokeswoman Jenna Lyle pointed to data indicating that 12% more NYC students passed Advanced Placement exams in 2024 compared to the previous year. This achievement demonstrates that NYC students are capable of challenging themselves and excelling academically when given the appropriate support and opportunities.
This success with Advanced Placement exams suggests that focusing on rigorous curriculum, providing dedicated instruction, and fostering a culture of high expectations can yield positive results. By replicating these strategies across all subjects and grade levels, NYC’s education system can begin to close the achievement gaps and improve outcomes for all students. This news demonstrates that it is possible for NYC students to experience success given the right resources.
The news about Advanced Placement success should serve as a call to action to expand these opportunities. A commitment to equity and access will ensure that more students, regardless of background or zip code, have the chance to participate in challenging academic programs and prepare for success in college and beyond. By expanding these opportunities, the city’s schools can begin to close the achievement gaps and improve outcomes for all students.
Digital SAT and Colleges Reversing Course on Testing
The College Board, which administers the SAT, transitioned the test to a fully digital format in the spring of 2024. It remains to be seen what effects, if any, this change has on student performance on the test. The transition to the test has been lauded for allowing students more flexibility in terms of test timing.
Additionally, many colleges stopped requiring SAT and ACT scores during the pandemic, but have recently reversed course. College readiness and success are directly correlated with SAT and ACT performance. With this in mind, colleges are moving back to ‘test required’ policies, as noted by Linda Quarles, a Brooklyn Tech parent and vice president of the Citywide Council on High Schools.
For students like Leo Niyazov, an 11th-grader at Brooklyn Technical High School and student at Kweller Prep, preparing for the SAT will up his chances of getting into West Point. He said, “Even though many colleges are test-optional now, West Point still requires the SAT … A strong SAT score helps strengthen my whole application.” He recognizes that in his situation, a strong SAT score can be a difference-maker in achieving his goals.
Looking Ahead: Investing in NYC Students
The declining SAT scores in New York City represent a serious challenge that requires immediate and sustained attention. The data paints a clear picture: NYC students are falling behind their peers across the state and nation, and significant score gaps exist among different racial and ethnic groups. Addressing this crisis demands a multifaceted approach that tackles the root causes of inequity and provides all students with the resources and support they need to succeed.
Investing in early childhood education, expanding access to high-quality teachers and curriculum, providing targeted tutoring programs, and addressing the social and economic factors that impact student achievement are all crucial steps. By prioritizing equity and ensuring that all students have the opportunity to reach their full potential, NYC can reverse this troubling trend and create a brighter future for generations to come. Now is the time for real change and accountability.
As Avish Jain, the Brooklyn Tech 11th-grader, noted, a comprehensive plan is needed to close the gaps in education. The crisis can be averted with increased support for students and schools. By doing so, NYC schools can help students succeed and meet national standards. More support is needed within schools, including guidance counseling, mentorship programs, and access to technology, which will help all students move toward a more level playing field.
Leave a Reply