Jerrod Carmichael is back, and he’s not holding anything back. In his new HBO special, “Don’t Be Gay,” Carmichael dives deep into his personal life, dissecting his relationships, his identity, and his place in the world. This isn’t just a comedy special; it’s a raw and unflinching exploration of what it means to be Jerrod Carmichael in 2025. It’s a compelling narrative that blends humor with uncomfortable truths, making you laugh while simultaneously prompting deep reflection.
Since publicly coming out in his Emmy-winning special “Rothaniel,” Carmichael has continued to push boundaries. “Don’t Be Gay” reflects on the aftermath of that revelation, tackling issues of internalized homophobia and racism with a characteristic blend of wit and vulnerability. The special isn’t just about being gay; it’s about the intersection of identity, and how the fear of being outed overshadowed other critical aspects of his life, like race.
In this review, we’ll break down the key moments of “Don’t Be Gay”, exploring Carmichael’s masterful storytelling and analyzing how he continues to challenge societal norms. We’ll delve into his reflections on family, love, and the complexities of navigating the world as a Black, gay man in America. This special is more than just entertainment; it’s a cultural commentary that demands attention.
The Evolution of Jerrod Carmichael: From Sitcoms to Stand-Up
Jerrod Carmichael has never been one to shy away from the spotlight, however his comedic evolution from sitcoms to stand-up specials showcases a willingness to confront difficult topics. Carmichael’s journey began with traditional sitcoms, but he quickly transitioned to a more introspective and boundary-pushing style of comedy. This evolution demonstrates his desire to engage with deeper, more meaningful themes.
His Emmy-winning special “Rothaniel” marked a turning point, as he publicly came out and explored his sexuality. This act of vulnerability resonated with audiences and critics alike, establishing Carmichael as a fearless voice in comedy. In “Don’t Be Gay,” Carmichael continues this trajectory, diving deeper into his personal experiences. As Aramide Tinubu from Variety writes, “Witty, brash, guttingly honest and slightly heartbreaking, in ‘Don’t Be Gay,’ Carmichael is reconciling how much the fear of being outed made him forget about the one other thing that affects his everyday life: racism. “
This evolution is not just about personal growth; it’s a reflection of changing cultural attitudes towards identity and representation. Carmichael’s willingness to explore these themes has made him a leading voice in contemporary comedy. “Don’t Be Gay” proves that he’s not content to rest on his laurels, continuing to push the boundaries of what comedy can be.
Confronting Internalized Homophobia: A Central Theme
A significant part of Carmichael’s special revolves around his struggles with internalized homophobia. He candidly discusses how the fear of being outed shaped his behavior and relationships. This theme is not just a personal confession; it’s a commentary on the societal pressures that LGBTQ+ individuals face.
Carmichael recalls reading online comments about his relationship with a white boyfriend, comments that questioned his identity. This experience prompted him to question whether he was “transforming into Clarence Thomas.” He tells the audience, “Why this n—- Jerrod got a white boyfriend?”. This moment encapsulates the complex intersection of race and sexuality that Carmichael navigates. His willingness to share these vulnerable moments makes the special all the more impactful.
By confronting his internalized homophobia, Carmichael encourages viewers to reflect on their own biases and assumptions. He uses comedy as a tool to dissect these complex issues, creating a space for dialogue and understanding. This theme resonates deeply in a world where LGBTQ+ individuals continue to face discrimination and prejudice.
Family and Faith: Navigating Challenging Relationships
Family dynamics, particularly his relationship with his hyper-religious mother, play a prominent role in “Don’t Be Gay.” Carmichael discusses the challenges of returning to his childhood home in North Carolina, where his parents still live. This exploration of family is both humorous and poignant, highlighting the complexities of love and acceptance.
Carmichael shares anecdotes about his mother’s unwavering faith and his own evolving views on religion. He remarks, “I’m gay, and n—-s don’t read,” highlighting the cultural divide between his identity and his upbringing. He also jokes that the church is actually a pyramid scheme, displaying his ability to find humor in serious subjects. Even though they have open relationship, he hates that his beau can also sleep with other people, but his own sexual appetite prevents him from being monogamous.
Though it seems unlikely Carmichael will ever have a close bond with his mother again, he seems to be at a point of acceptance. However, he is now more certain than ever that the institution of the church is actually a pyramid scheme. He also seems resigned to be the official breadwinner for his entire family – a dichotomy that makes him feel pride and a bit like a scroogey Reagan-era Republican.
Despite these challenges, Carmichael approaches his family with empathy and understanding. He acknowledges the difficulty of bridging ideological gaps, but he also emphasizes the importance of maintaining connections. This theme speaks to the universal struggle of reconciling personal identity with familial expectations.
Honesty and Vulnerability: The Keys to Carmichael’s Comedy
What sets Jerrod Carmichael apart is his unflinching honesty and vulnerability. He doesn’t shy away from sharing uncomfortable truths, whether it’s about his own flaws or societal issues. This willingness to be open and authentic is what makes his comedy so compelling.
In “Don’t Be Gay,” Carmichael discusses his struggles with infidelity and the pain he has caused his partner. He reflects on his inability to be truthful and express his feelings, admitting that he has hurt and devastated his partner. Even amid these deeply uncomfortable and sometimes cringy moments, Carmichael’s self-awareness is always palpable.
By sharing his personal shame, Carmichael exposes the social ills that have tried to stop him from being his true self. He turns personal experiences into universal lessons, inviting viewers to confront their own vulnerabilities. This honesty is refreshing in a world where authenticity is often sacrificed for the sake of appearances.
A Master Storyteller: Carmichael’s Comedic Prowess
Jerrod Carmichael is, above all, a master storyteller. He weaves together personal anecdotes, social commentary, and comedic observations into a cohesive and engaging narrative. His ability to connect with audiences on an emotional level is what makes his comedy so impactful.
His standup special is full of laugh-out-loud punchlines, but the comedian also doesn’t shy away from darker themes. He reflects on child funerals, very graphic and specific sexual acts that get him off and also how he’s hurt and continually devastated his partner because of his inability to be truthful and express his feelings.
In this “Rothaniel” follow-up, Carmichael has never seemed more confident. A master storyteller, he leans into the relief he feels about no longer being closeted while considering his remaining discomfort over PDA. Despite their open relationship, he hates that his beau can also sleep with other people, but his own sexual appetite prevents him from being monogamous. Carmichael is content to share his personal shame while exposing the social ills that have also tried to stop him from being his true self. Once again, the comedian has mastered the beauty of standing directly in his truth.
“Don’t Be Gay” has more levity than “Rothaniel”– Carmichael has a sense of liberation that only comes after facing your worst fears.
Whether he’s discussing waffle obsessions, Grindr encounters, or family dynamics, Carmichael’s storytelling is always sharp and insightful. He has a unique ability to find humor in the mundane and to extract profound meaning from everyday experiences.
Conclusion: The Enduring Impact of Jerrod Carmichael
Jerrod Carmichael’s “Don’t Be Gay” is more than just a comedy special; it’s a cultural artifact that speaks to the complexities of identity, family, and society. Carmichael’s honesty, vulnerability, and masterful storytelling make this special a must-watch for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of themselves and the world around them.
In this special, Carmichael is content to share his personal shame while exposing the social ills that have also tried to stop him from being his true self. “Don’t Be Gay” has more levity than “Rothaniel”– Carmichael has a sense of liberation that only comes after facing your worst fears. Once again, the comedian has mastered the beauty of standing directly in his truth.
Carmichael’s journey from sitcoms to stand-up specials is a testament to his artistic growth and his commitment to pushing boundaries. He has emerged as a leading voice in contemporary comedy, challenging societal norms and encouraging dialogue around difficult issues. As Aramide Tinubu wrote, “Jerrod Carmichael’s ‘Don’t Be Gay’ Proves the Comedian Is a Master Storyteller.”
Leave a Reply