The 2025 Monaco Grand Prix sparked heated debate, with Jenson Button leading the charge against what he deemed ‘silly’ team tactics and a ‘mockery’ of racing. George Russell’s controversial off-track maneuver on Alex Albon epitomized the strategic chaos, born from Formula 1’s mandated two-stop strategy. This article delves into the criticisms, exploring how the race’s innovative rule intended to improve racing arguably backfired, prioritizing pit strategy over on-track excitement. We’ll examine the specific incidents, the drivers’ reactions, and the contrasting opinions of other F1 legends like Martin Brundle and Damon Hill.
Two-Stop Tactic: Innovation or Impediment?
After last year’s no-stopping Monaco Grand Prix, the result of a red flag on the opening lap that allowed the drivers to change their tyres in a free pit stop, Formula 1 implemented a mandatory two-stop strategy for this year’s Grand Prix. It was hailed as an innovative idea to improve the racing, but the only thing it had an impact on was strategy. While some drivers completed both tyre changes early, others waited until the final laps, leading to strategic games and frustrations.
Team Orders: Racing Bulls and Williams Under Scrutiny
In the midst of it all, some teams, notably Racing Bulls and Williams, played the team-mate game. Racing Bulls started it as Liam Lawson backed off to make a gap for Isack Hadjar to pit – not once but twice – before Williams followed suit as Carlos Sainz held up the field for Alex Albon. Given the Williams team-mates were the drivers right in front of George Russell, their antics frustrated the Mercedes driver who, having called out Albon for “dangerously slow” driving, cut the Nouvelle Chicane and told Mercedes that he was okay with copping a penalty for doing it.
Pitting Dominated Monaco GP
The race was won by Lando Norris ahead of Charles Leclerc, Oscar Piastri and Max Verstappen – the lead quartet finishing as they started. Although it is fair to say the race did offer more strategies and more questions, what it didn’t provide was more on-track excitement with everything done in the pits. “When teams were using one driver to help another and going six seconds a lap slower, it looked a bit silly,” Button said during Sky F1’s coverage. “Then we had George trying to jump Albon through the chicane to get in front and push on, again, it makes a bit of a mockery of it. It hasn’t worked. I love that we tried it but we need to work out a way of tweaking it.
Drivers Frustrations
As a kid, eight years old, you look at F1 as the pinnacle and think you want to get there because you drive fast. Then you come to Monaco and it’s about driving as slow as you can for your team-mate. And the drivers are embarrassed but they did what they had to [in order] to score points. His fellow pundit and former F1 driver Martin Brundle rued a race dominated by pitting, not racing. “It didn’t work, did it?” said Brundle. “The focus was on pitting and not on racing. I don’t want to see drivers all the way through the field playing a game. This is about excellence, about the highest point of motorsport and I don’t like to see so many drivers going slowly.”
Damon Hill Disagrees
However, 1996 World Champion Damon Hill disagreed with his compatriots as he felt the rule worked as it opened to the various strategies, one that could’ve even seen Verstappen win from fourth on the grid. The Dutchman was the very last of the frontrunners to make his second stop, doing so only on the penultimate lap as he led the latter part of the race hoping for a Safety Car to give him a free pit stop. It didn’t materialise and he fell back to fourth when he pitted, but it was at least another strategy conundrum in the mix. “Clearly not an epic grand prix race but I thought the 3 tyre rule worked,” he wrote on Twitter. “Max gambled on a stopped race. It didn’t work, but it might have. Meanwhile, Lando is back on course for a World Championship. Looked like a very focused racer. A perfect weekend.”
Monaco Grand Prix: A Strategic Puzzle
The 2025 Monaco Grand Prix, intended to be a thrilling spectacle of racing, instead became a strategic conundrum. Jenson Button’s critique highlighted the perceived flaws of the mandatory two-stop rule, which he believed led to ‘silly’ team tactics and detracted from the on-track excitement. While some, like Damon Hill, saw the merit in the strategic diversity it created, the dominant sentiment leaned towards disappointment. The focus shifted from driver skill and speed to pit strategy and team orders, leaving many to question the direction of Formula 1’s most iconic race. Ultimately, the 2025 Monaco Grand Prix serves as a case study in the delicate balance between innovation and tradition, and the ongoing quest to enhance the sport’s appeal without sacrificing its core values.
Leave a Reply