The debate rages on in Edmonton: Should the Oilers keep Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl together on one line, or split them up to diversify their offensive attack? There’s no definitive answer, as the optimal strategy depends heavily on the game’s context and the team’s needs at any given moment. The decision to unite these two superstars represents a nuclear option, a potent tool that can shift momentum and tilt the ice in the Oilers’ favor.
This article delves into the nuances of this strategic quandary, exploring insights from former coaches and current perspectives on how best to utilize McDavid and Draisaitl. By examining their impact both together and apart, we aim to uncover the factors that drive the decision-making process. Ultimately, the goal is to determine when unleashing this dynamic duo can lead the Oilers to victory.
Ken Hitchcock’s Wisdom: Balancing Act
Former Oilers head coach Ken Hitchcock offered a balanced perspective on the McDavid-Draisaitl dilemma. According to Hitchcock, the team benefits most when these two players are separated, creating a more balanced offensive structure. However, he acknowledged the undeniable impact of uniting them during crucial moments.
“They like playing together, but the team needs them split up,” Hitchcock explained. “But when it’s crunch time and there needs to be a change in the way the game is being played and you put those two guys together, it makes all kinds of sense. Playing them apart balances everything, but they are almost unstoppable when they are together.”
Hitchcock’s insight highlights the strategic flexibility required to maximize the team’s potential. While separation fosters depth and balance, the option to combine McDavid and Draisaitl provides an unparalleled offensive surge when needed most.
Dave Tippett’s View: A Momentum Changer
Dave Tippett, another former Oilers head coach, echoed Hitchcock’s sentiment, emphasizing the value of McDavid and Draisaitl as a game-changing tool. Tippett sees their reunion as a strategic maneuver to shift momentum, break down matchups, and gain a decisive advantage.
“It is a great tool to use as a momentum-changer, matchup-breaker or, as a coach would say, ’tilt the ice in our favor,’” Tippett noted. “They are both very smart players who love playing together but also recognize the advantages to the team when they are apart. The debate shouldn’t be, ‘Should they play together or apart?’ It is, ‘What is the best situation for the team to win at any point in the game?’”
Tippett’s perspective underscores the importance of adaptability. The decision to unite McDavid and Draisaitl should not be viewed as a permanent solution, but rather as a tactical adjustment based on the evolving dynamics of the game.
Kris Knoblauch’s Inheritance: The Nuclear Option
Current Oilers head coach Kris Knoblauch inherited this strategic puzzle and has been experimenting with different approaches. In Game 1 of the Stanley Cup Final against the Florida Panthers, Knoblauch deployed the “nuclear option,” reuniting McDavid and Draisaitl to shift the game’s momentum.
“I’ve done it throughout the playoffs, mid-game or third period — they have just gone off and scored at a tremendous rate,” Knoblauch said. “A couple of big games in the L.A. series. There’s also games where they’ve started together and played well but haven’t scored like you would expect. I don’t know. I think it’s important when Leon is playing center. It spreads out our scoring a little bit and also gets him in the game a little bit more. He’s skating and involved.”
Knoblauch recognizes the potency of this combination, but he also understands the importance of balance. He aims to empower the entire team, ensuring that they don’t become overly reliant on McDavid and Draisaitl.
The Impact on Team Depth: Empowering the Wingers
A Western Conference head coach, who chose to remain anonymous, highlighted the positive impact of separating McDavid and Draisaitl on the team’s depth. According to this coach, spreading out the two stars empowers the wingers, leading to a more balanced offensive attack.
“What I’ve noticed is that when they separate them, they get more from the wingers. I always find (Ryan) Nugent-Hopkins a better player with McDavid than if he has to drive his own line. It’s the same with (Kasperi) Kapanen. He wasn’t even in the lineup, but when he’s playing with Draisaitl, that’s the end-result benefit of spreading the two big guys.”
This perspective suggests that the Oilers’ supporting cast thrives when given the opportunity to play alongside either McDavid or Draisaitl, fostering a more competitive and well-rounded team.
Analytics Insight: Trust and Defensive Prowess
Dom Luszczyszyn, an analytics expert, examined the Oilers’ increased deployment of McDavid and Draisaitl together during the playoffs. Luszczyszyn identified two key factors driving this trend: trust in the team’s depth and confidence in the stars’ defensive abilities.
“The first is the team trusting its depth to contribute offensively without risking the puck going the other way…The second is the team trusting its franchise stars to shut things down defensively.”
Luszczyszyn’s analysis reveals a shift in the Oilers’ strategy, highlighting their increased reliance on McDavid and Draisaitl not only for offense but also for defensive stability.
Paul Maurice’s Preparedness: Anticipating the Move
Panthers head coach Paul Maurice has extensive experience coaching against the McDavid-Draisaitl combination. He understands the challenges it presents and has developed strategies to mitigate their impact.
“Well, at some point, because they’re together, you have a better indicator of when they’re coming off the bench,” Maurice explained. “It’s slightly more of a challenge on the road. So you need to have more than one line (to match up) against them…”
Maurice’s preparedness underscores the importance of anticipating and adapting to the Oilers’ strategic deployment of their two superstars.
Evander Kane’s Take: Depth and Contribution
Oilers winger Evander Kane emphasized the importance of the team’s depth in supporting the McDavid-Draisaitl strategy. Kane believes that the Oilers’ increased depth allows the coaching staff to deploy the two stars together without sacrificing the team’s overall offensive output.
“It’s on the rest of the group to step up and contribute as well when you don’t have them going 1-2 down the middle. I thought we did a good job of that in the latter half of the game.”
Kane’s perspective highlights the collective effort required to make the McDavid-Draisaitl strategy work effectively.
Hitchcock’s Reflection: Survival vs. Strategy
Hitchcock reflected on his past experiences coaching the Oilers, noting that his decision to unite McDavid and Draisaitl was often driven by necessity rather than strategic design. He believes that the current Oilers team has the depth to make the strategy a more viable option.
“Yeah, well, for me, they were the best two players and it was just survival when I was doing it,” Hitchcock chuckled. “We needed that element in our game. Whereas now, they’ve got guys that can really bring it and are good players. They can afford to spread it out a little bit more and have more offense.”
Hitchcock’s reflection underscores the evolution of the Oilers’ roster and the increased strategic flexibility they now possess.
Conclusion: A Dynamic Strategy for Success
The decision to keep Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl together or split them up is a complex strategic choice that depends on numerous factors. Insights from former coaches, current perspectives, and analytical data all contribute to a nuanced understanding of the optimal approach. Ultimately, the Oilers’ success hinges on their ability to adapt their strategy based on the evolving dynamics of each game.
The “nuclear option” of uniting McDavid and Draisaitl remains a potent tool in the Oilers’ arsenal. However, it is crucial to recognize the importance of team depth and defensive stability in supporting this strategy. As the Oilers navigate the challenges of the Stanley Cup Final, their ability to effectively deploy their two superstars will undoubtedly play a pivotal role in their quest for victory.
Leave a Reply