The debate over the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history is a timeless tradition, fueling endless discussions and passionate arguments. Recently, a list ranking the top 30 quarterbacks of all time ignited fresh controversy, particularly for Pittsburgh Steelers fans. The list, compiled by NFL columnist Tyler Dunne, placed Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen ahead of Steelers legend Terry Bradshaw, raising eyebrows and sparking heated debate. This article will delve into the details of the ranking, explore the arguments for and against Allen’s placement, and examine how other Steelers quarterbacks fared on the list.
The ranking highlights the evolving landscape of the NFL and the unique skill sets that modern quarterbacks bring to the game. While Bradshaw’s legacy is firmly etched in NFL history, Allen’s dynamic play and immense potential have earned him a spot among the greats. This article breaks down Dunne’s assessment, offering context and analysis for fans to understand the reasoning behind the controversial ranking.
Josh Allen vs. Terry Bradshaw: A Generational Showdown
Tyler Dunne’s ranking places Josh Allen at No. 15 and Terry Bradshaw at No. 16. This close proximity invites direct comparison. Dunne praises Allen as a ‘force of nature’ with a unique blend of size, arm strength, athleticism, and fearlessness. The article quotes Dunne saying, ‘There is no comp because no quarterback in NFL history remotely resembles the force of nature cannon-blasting through defenses in Western New York.’
While Bradshaw led the Steelers to four Super Bowl titles in the 1970s, Allen’s modern style of play has captivated fans. He is a dual-threat quarterback, excelling both as a passer and a runner. Bradshaw, known for his toughness and leadership, played in a different era with different expectations for the quarterback position.
Tyler Dunne’s Rationale
Dunne’s analysis emphasizes Allen’s potential to become an all-time great. ‘When it’s all said and done — if he can hoist a Lombardi or two — we may all discuss Allen with the very best who’ve ever played the position,’ Dunne writes. This suggests that Allen’s current ranking is based on his trajectory and potential impact on the game, not solely on past achievements.
The article also highlights the intangible qualities that make Allen a special player. Dunne notes that ‘Teammates en masse would run through the nearest cement wall for Allen,’ underscoring his leadership and ability to inspire his team. While Bradshaw was also a respected leader, Allen’s unique charisma and playing style have resonated with a new generation of fans.
Other Steelers Quarterbacks on the List
The article also mentions the rankings of other notable Steelers quarterbacks. Aaron Rodgers, who currently plays for the Steelers, sits at No. 10 on the list. Terry Bradshaw is ranked 14th. This provides context for Bradshaw’s ranking and demonstrates that Dunne’s list is not solely focused on contemporary players.
The inclusion of multiple Steelers quarterbacks on the list underscores the franchise’s rich history and legacy at the position. From Bradshaw’s Super Bowl victories to Rodgers’s sustained excellence, the Steelers have consistently fielded talented quarterbacks who have shaped the NFL landscape.
Fan Reaction and Controversy
The ranking has sparked debate among Steelers fans, many of whom disagree with Allen being placed ahead of Bradshaw. The article acknowledges this sentiment, stating, ‘You won’t find many Steelers fans out there who will agree with Allen over Bradshaw.’ This highlights the subjective nature of quarterback rankings and the strong emotional connection fans have with their favorite players.
n
While some fans may dismiss Dunne’s ranking as biased or disrespectful, others recognize the validity of his arguments. Allen’s unique skill set and potential for future success cannot be ignored, even if they challenge traditional notions of quarterback greatness. The controversy surrounding the ranking ultimately fuels discussion and encourages fans to engage with the history of the game.
Aaron Rodgers’s Position
The article briefly mentions that Steelers’ current quarterback Aaron Rodgers also tops Roethlisberger, sitting 10th on the list. It also notes that Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes top the list at No. 1 and No. 2 respectively. This puts Roethlisberger in good company, surrounded by other legendary quarterbacks.
Seeing Rodgers ranked higher than Bradshaw may also stir some debate. Considering Rodgers hasn’t yet made a significant impact with the Steelers at the time of this article’s publishing (June 28, 2025), some Steelers fans may believe it is premature to rank him so high compared to a franchise legend.
Conclusion: A Shifting Perspective on Quarterback Greatness
The ranking of Josh Allen ahead of Terry Bradshaw on Tyler Dunne’s list is a testament to the changing dynamics of the NFL. While Bradshaw’s Super Bowl victories and traditional quarterbacking skills remain highly valued, Allen’s athleticism, arm strength, and potential for future success have earned him a place among the greats. The debate surrounding this ranking underscores the subjective nature of evaluating quarterbacks and the importance of considering different eras and playing styles.
Ultimately, both Allen and Bradshaw have left an indelible mark on the NFL. Bradshaw’s leadership and toughness helped define the Steelers dynasty of the 1970s, while Allen’s dynamic play has revitalized the Buffalo Bills franchise. As the NFL continues to evolve, quarterback rankings will inevitably spark controversy and debate, but they also provide an opportunity to celebrate the rich history and talent at the position.
Leave a Reply