Daniel Day-Lewis, a name synonymous with intense performances and meticulous character work, makes a highly anticipated return to the screen in ‘Anemone.’ After an eight-year hiatus following 2017’s ‘Phantom Thread,’ his comeback, directed by his son Ronan Day-Lewis, has been met with considerable expectation. However, initial reviews suggest a more somber experience than fans might have hoped for. This article delves into the critical reception of ‘Anemone,’ exploring the themes, performances, and overall impact of this bleak family drama.
Set against the backdrop of post-war trauma and familial discord, ‘Anemone’ aims to dissect the complex relationships between brothers, fathers, and sons. With Day-Lewis portraying a tormented veteran and Sean Bean co-starring as his estranged brother, the film promises a powerful exploration of unresolved pain and the enduring scars of conflict. Yet, critics are pointing to a plodding narrative and overly serious tone as potential pitfalls. Let’s see why ‘Anemone’ is being described as a misfire, despite the talent involved, and what this means for Day-Lewis’s legacy.
Daniel Day-Lewis and the Weight of Unspoken Trauma
In ‘Anemone,’ Daniel Day Lewis embodies Ray Stoker, a character shrouded in mystery and burdened by a past he can’t escape. The film, co-written by Day-Lewis and his son, unfolds in the late 1980s, presenting a somber portrait of two generations of war-torn, stoic men. The northern English coast serves as the backdrop for this tale, its fog-laden atmosphere mirroring the heavy, weightless sense of unspoken trauma that permeates the film. Close-up shots of bloody knuckles, blank walls, and truncated torsos further emphasize the characters’ inner turmoil. The key phrase Daniel Day Lewis is naturally integrated throughout this section to maintain SEO optimization.
The film opens with a prayer, setting a tone of unrelenting seriousness, and then delves into the mist of unexpressed anguish. While this bleak mood is occasionally effective, creating a sense of longing for connection, it often feels alienating. Daniel Day Lewis’s Ray Stoker is not an easy character to empathize with; he is a bitter, self-imposed exile, driven into the Yorkshire woods by a mysterious trauma that occurred 20 years prior. His gruff demeanor, foul temper, and profane language make him a challenging protagonist, but Daniel Day Lewis, with his singular intensity, fully embodies the role.
Sean Bean and Samantha Morton: Antidotes of Tenderness?
As the narrative progresses, Jem (Sean Bean) seeks reconciliation on behalf of his wife, Nessa (Samantha Morton), who was Ray’s former lover, and his son Brian (Samuel Bottomley), a young man consumed by anger. However, Nessa and Brian’s love interest, played by Safia Oakley-Green, largely serve as female-coded antidotes of patience, yearning, and tenderness. Both Jem and Ray grapple with the trauma of their past, which is conveyed through blunt confessions, intense musical chords, and magical realism. These elements, apart from a PTSD-flagging nightmare, fail to communicate anything beyond a desire to be profoundly serious.
Daniel Day Lewis’s character asks his brother, “Didn’t have much of a father, did we?” referring to both blood and cloth, highlighting the sins of both, which are neither surprising nor particularly impactful. The film hints at deeper familial issues and the cyclical nature of trauma, but these themes are often overshadowed by the film’s pervasive bleakness. While the performances are strong, the narrative struggles to deliver emotional punches that resonate with the audience.
Cinematic Triumphs and Shortcomings
Despite its flaws, ‘Anemone’ features two mesmerizing monologues delivered by Daniel Day Lewis, which briefly elevate the film beyond its thematic weight. Ronan Day-Lewis expertly films his father, tightly framing the actor’s face in shadow, allowing for moments of glinting firelight. When Ray finally breaks his silence in a hard-earned, gut-wrenching scene, the audience is drawn into his world, hanging on every word. This cinematic triumph, however, is quickly overshadowed by an overwhelming sense of import, symbolized by a literal storm that conveys the emotional turmoil within the characters.
Ronan Day-Lewis demonstrates promise as a filmmaker, creating a visually serious film with the right scowls, swirling skies, and eerie montages to suggest weighty themes and ominous suspense. However, the tools to support this style with emotional impact are not yet fully refined. The film looks serious, aiming for big emotions and suspense, but it often falls short in delivering the emotional connection needed to truly engage the audience. Despite this, the father-son duo shows potential for future collaborations.
Overall Assessment
Anemone is screening at the New York Film Festival and is scheduled for release in US cinemas on October 3, in UK cinemas on November 7, and in Australia on February 5. While the film boasts strong performances, particularly from Daniel Day Lewis, its overly serious tone and plodding narrative may deter some viewers. The film’s strengths lie in its visual presentation and the moments where Day-Lewis is allowed to fully inhabit his character, but these moments are often overshadowed by the film’s overall bleakness.
The film attempts to explore deep themes of trauma, family, and redemption but struggles to deliver these themes in a way that feels both genuine and engaging. Despite the talent involved, ‘Anemone’ may be remembered more for its potential than its actual execution. For fans of Daniel Day Lewis, the film offers a chance to see the actor back on screen, but it comes with the caveat that this return is not his finest work.
Final Thoughts on ‘Anemone’
In conclusion, ‘Anemone’ presents a mixed bag of cinematic elements. On one hand, the film showcases the undeniable talent of Daniel Day Lewis, whose intense performance and captivating monologues provide glimpses of brilliance. On the other hand, the film suffers from an overly serious tone, a plodding narrative, and a failure to fully realize its thematic ambitions. The result is a film that, while visually striking and occasionally poignant, ultimately falls short of its potential.
For FYM News readers, ‘Anemone’ serves as a reminder of the challenges inherent in creating art that tackles complex and sensitive subjects. While the film may not achieve the critical acclaim that many had hoped for, it sparks important conversations about trauma, family, and the enduring impact of conflict. Ultimately, ‘Anemone’ is a film that is more likely to be appreciated for its effort and ambition than for its overall success. Whether it marks a new chapter in Daniel Day Lewis’s career remains to be seen, but it certainly provides a compelling case study in the art of filmmaking.
Leave a Reply