“Be humble. Sit down.” —Kendrick Lamar
“I deserve it all.”—Kendrick Lamar
“We never seen anything like this.”—Stephen A. Smith
The 2024 NFL Draft was full of surprises, but few were as shocking as the slide of Shedeur Sanders. Projected as a potential first-round pick, Sanders watched as team after team passed on him, until the Cleveland Browns selected him in the fifth round. This article delves into the possible reasons behind this unexpected drop, exploring factors beyond football performance, including perceptions of confidence and the complex dynamics of race and representation in the NFL. We’ll examine the concept of “know-your-place aggression,” the influence of Deion Sanders’ legacy, and potential issues surrounding player representation and agency. Ultimately, we aim to shed light on the forces that may have contributed to Shedeur Sanders’ draft day experience.
The Draft Day Plunge
Shedeur Sanders’ draft day was nothing short of dramatic. Opting to celebrate at his home in Canton, Texas, surrounded by family and branded with his “Legendary” logo, Sanders exuded confidence. A shelf filled with hats representing all 32 NFL teams symbolized his anticipation of being a high first-round pick. However, as the picks rolled in, Sanders’ name remained uncalled, leading to a precipitous fall down the draft board.
Considered a top prospect after a stellar college season, where he set Colorado records with 37 touchdowns and led the FBS in completion percentage (74%), Sanders’ resume was impressive. With no major off-field scandals and a composed demeanor under intense scrutiny, his slide was puzzling. The question arose: how could a player with such credentials fall out of the first, second, or even third round?
The Legacy of Deion Sanders
The answer may lie, in part, with the legacy of his father, Deion Sanders. Drafted in 1989, Deion’s confidence and willingness to dictate the terms of his career raised eyebrows. His flashy style and unapologetic self-promotion, evident in his “Prime Time” persona, challenged the norms of the time. This confidence, instilled in his sons, carries both advantages and disadvantages.
While Deion’s guidance undoubtedly contributed to Shedeur’s success, the Sanders family’s “cocky confidence” risks rubbing some the wrong way. Some may view humility, even if feigned, as a prerequisite for successful Black men, leading to attempts to “chasten” those deemed lacking in modesty. This dynamic plays a significant role in understanding Shedeur’s draft experience.
“Shedeur didn’t fall. He was knocked down, pushed down, held down. But why?”
Beyond Football Business
Under Deion’s leadership, Shedeur boosted ticket sales, merchandise revenue, and national TV exposure for his team. Drafting Shedeur would have been a lucrative business decision for any team, promising increased revenue and media attention. The fact that all 32 teams passed on him multiple times suggests that the rationale extended beyond pure football considerations.
The Browns, who ultimately drafted Shedeur, undoubtedly recognized the potential benefits. However, the hesitation of other teams raises questions about the influence of factors beyond the field. The decision-making process appears to have been influenced by something other than a simple assessment of his football abilities and potential marketability.
The Agent-Free Approach
Shedeur Sanders, like other recent top picks such as negotiated his contract without a traditional agent, using Deion as his advisor. This is an anomaly in the NFL, where only a small percentage of players negotiate their contracts independently. This trend poses a threat to the established ecosystem of professional sports, potentially leading to efforts to discourage players from representing themselves.
Crashing Shedeur’s draft value could serve as a deterrent to other players considering agent-free representation. By falling to the fifth round, Sanders lost out on a significant amount of potential earnings, sending a message about the risks of challenging the traditional agent system.
Know-Your-Place Aggression
The treatment of Shedeur Sanders can be viewed through the lens of “know-your-place aggression,” a term coined by Dr. Koritha Mitchell. This concept describes the targeting of Black people perceived as “uppity,” those who have achieved success, celebrate their accomplishments, or refuse to conform to societal expectations. Such individuals are often subjected to efforts to humble or humiliate them.
In a world where white people dominate, “uppity” Black individuals are often expected to remain humble and grateful. When they deviate from this script, they risk being penalized or put “in their place.” The NFL’s treatment of Shedeur Sanders, perceived by some as lacking humility, may be an example of this phenomenon.
Sociopolitical Context
The draft occurred during a period of heightened racial tension and political polarization. Corporate America’s retreat from diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, along with efforts to erase Black history and suppress Black voices, contribute to a climate of hostility and injustice. In this context, the microaggressions of the past have evolved into more blatant displays of power and control.
The fact that there is still not a single Black majority owner of an NFL team underscores the deep-seated inequalities within the league. While the Sanderses have not been overtly political, Deion’s statement about not wanting Shedeur to play for certain teams may have been perceived as a challenge to the established order.
A Model of Resilience
Despite the disappointment of draft day, the Sanderses have presented themselves as resilient and unfazed. Their handling of the situation with style, grace, and humor serves as a model for others facing similar challenges. The video of Shedeur and Shilo celebrating his selection by the Browns, with genuine elation, exemplifies their unwavering spirit.
Shedeur’s expression of gratitude to the Browns organization and the fans demonstrates his focus on the future. His ability to remain positive and determined in the face of adversity highlights his character and potential for future success, proving that the “devil” didn’t win on draft day.
Final Thoughts
Shedeur Sanders’ draft day slide was a complex event influenced by a confluence of factors. While his talent and potential are undeniable, perceptions of confidence, the legacy of Deion Sanders, issues surrounding player representation, and the broader sociopolitical climate all appear to have played a role. Ultimately, the saga serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by Black athletes navigating a predominantly white space.
The Sanders family’s response to the situation provides a powerful lesson in resilience and self-belief. As Shedeur embarks on his NFL career, his story serves as an inspiration to others facing adversity, proving that with determination and faith, it is possible to overcome even the most daunting obstacles. Only time will tell what Shedeur Sanders accomplishes in the NFL, but one thing is certain: he will continue to challenge expectations and defy limitations.
Leave a Reply