The latest episode of Criminal Minds: Evolution on Paramount+ delivered a bittersweet reunion for fans. While the team mourned the loss of a beloved character, subtle yet significant mentions and even a surprise appearance offered a comforting nod to the show’s rich history. This article delves into the details of Matthew Gray Gubler’s return as Reid, alongside other OG character references, and what it means for the future of the series.
Criminal Minds, since its debut in 2005, has navigated cast changes and explored a myriad of fictional cases, solidifying its place in television history. The revival, Criminal Minds: Evolution, continues this legacy, balancing new narratives with echoes of the past. The recent episode masterfully intertwines these elements, creating an emotional and nostalgic experience for long-time viewers.
In this article, we’ll explore:
- The emotional funeral episode and its impact
- Matthew Gray Gubler’s return as Reid and the reactions
- References to Aaron Hotchner and Derek Morgan
- Showrunner Erica Messer’s insights on bringing back OG characters
- Matthew Gray Gubler’s other projects, including CBS’s Einstein
Will’s Funeral: An Emotional Nucleus
The episode centers around the funeral of JJ’s husband, Will (Josh Stewart), a storyline that tugged at the heartstrings of many viewers. The somber occasion brought together Penelope Garcia (Kirsten Vangsness) and Emily Prentiss (Paget Brewster), offering solace and support to JJ (A.J. Cook) during her time of grief. The performances during these scenes were particularly poignant, reflecting the deep bonds forged over years of working together on gruesome cases.
The setting of a funeral naturally evokes reflection, and the writers used this to their advantage. As JJ prepared for the service, the dialogue was laced with memories and unspoken sentiments, allowing the characters – and the audience – to reminisce about the past. This created a fertile ground for the introduction of familiar faces and mentions of beloved characters who are no longer series regulars.
The emotional weight of Will’s death provided a catalyst for character interactions and plot developments, setting the stage for a narrative that honored the past while embracing the present. The episode served as a reminder of the personal sacrifices often made by those in law enforcement and the emotional toll it takes on their families.
“It was important for us to acknowledge the loss and allow the characters to grieve,” said showrunner Erica Messer in a behind-the-scenes interview. “Will’s death impacts everyone, and we wanted to honor his memory in a meaningful way.”
The funeral scene was not just a plot point; it was a character-driven exploration of loss, memory, and the enduring bonds that define the Criminal Minds family.
Matthew Gray Gubler’s Return as Reid
The most anticipated moment of the episode was undoubtedly the return of Matthew Gray Gubler as Dr. Spencer Reid. Although Gubler had been absent from Criminal Minds: Evolution, his presence was deeply felt by fans who have followed his character’s journey since the show’s inception. The emotional day was heightened when Gubler’s fan-favorite character made an appearance. This cameo was more than just a brief scene; it was a symbolic gesture of solidarity and a testament to the character’s lasting impact on the series.
Gubler’s portrayal of Reid has always been a fan favorite, and his return was met with widespread excitement and relief. Social media platforms lit up with messages of joy and appreciation, underscoring the character’s importance to the show’s identity. The scene was carefully crafted to maximize its emotional impact, creating a moment that resonated with both the characters on screen and the viewers at home.
The return was subtle, yet powerful, serving as a reminder of Reid’s integral role within the BAU team. His presence provided a sense of continuity, bridging the gap between the original series and the revival. This careful handling of a beloved character ensured that his return felt organic and respectful to his established arc.
“We knew that bringing Matthew back would be a significant moment for the fans,” Messer explained. “We wanted to make sure it felt right and honored the character’s history. It was a decision we didn’t take lightly.”
Matthew Gray Gubler’s appearance as Reid was a testament to the enduring appeal of Criminal Minds and the deep connection between the show and its audience.
Hotchner and Morgan: Acknowledging the Past
Beyond Reid’s physical return, the episode also included heartfelt mentions of Aaron Hotchner (Thomas Gibson) and Derek Morgan (Shemar Moore). Emily Prentiss pointed out to Penelope that both Hotchner and Morgan sent flowers, expressing their inability to attend the funeral in person. These references were particularly meaningful, considering the characters’ significant roles in the original series.
The decision to acknowledge Hotchner and Morgan was a strategic move to honor the show’s history and pay respect to characters who were once central to the narrative. Despite the actors’ departures, their characters remain an important part of the Criminal Minds universe, and their absence is still felt by both the team and the audience.
These subtle nods were well-received by viewers, many of whom expressed appreciation for the show’s commitment to continuity. It demonstrated a willingness to acknowledge the past while moving forward with new storylines and character arcs. The mentions served as a comforting reminder of the bonds that were forged over years of working together on the BAU team.
“We always want to honor the characters who have been a part of this show,” Messer said. “Even if they can’t be physically present, we want to acknowledge their contributions and keep their memory alive.”
By referencing Hotchner and Morgan, the episode solidified the sense of community that has always been a hallmark of Criminal Minds, reinforcing the idea that the past is never truly forgotten.
Erica Messer on Bringing Back OG Characters
In an exclusive interview with Us Weekly in July 2024, showrunner Erica Messer discussed the challenges and desires of bringing back original characters to Criminal Minds: Evolution. Messer emphasized that Matthew Gray Gubler is considered a part of the family, and there is always a desire to find an opportunity for him to return.
Messer explained that despite efforts from both sides, scheduling conflicts have made it difficult for Gubler to participate in the revival. However, she assured fans that the lack of physical appearances does not reflect a lack of interest or commitment. The show continues to find creative ways to reference Reid and other former team members, ensuring that their presence is still felt.
Messer’s insights provide valuable context for understanding the complexities of managing a long-running series and the challenges of coordinating schedules with actors who have moved on to other projects. Her commitment to honoring the show’s history and characters is evident in the subtle yet meaningful ways that the past is integrated into the present narrative.
“It just hasn’t worked out timing wise. I can’t speak to [season 3 of Criminal Minds: Evolution] because we’re not there yet. But it’s not for lack of trying,” Messer said. “I think the characters also are going to acknowledge it.”
Erica Messer’s dedication to the Criminal Minds legacy highlights the importance of honoring the past while forging new paths for the series.
Matthew Gray Gubler’s Other Projects: CBS’s Einstein
While Matthew Gray Gubler isn’t currently reprising his role as Reid in Criminal Minds: Evolution, he is set to make his TV return in CBS’s Einstein. This new series offers a different perspective on Gubler’s talents, showcasing him in a role that diverges from the intense and complex character of Dr. Spencer Reid.
In Einstein, Gubler plays Lew Einstein, the great-grandson of Albert Einstein, who uses his genius to help a local police detective solve puzzling cases. The show promises to blend elements of crime-solving with humor and eccentric character dynamics. However, the series has faced some delays, with CBS pushing its premiere from the 2025-26 TV season to the 2026-27 season.
The network’s decision to delay the premiere reflects a strategic approach to maximizing the show’s chances of success. By allowing more time for development and promotion, CBS hopes to ensure that Einstein captures a wide audience and establishes itself as a strong contender in the competitive television landscape.
“We felt like Einstein could really benefit from this path, even if it means changing course. We are not afraid to do that when it means that we are setting the show up for its best chances of success,” said CBS Entertainment President Amy Reisenbach.
Matthew Gray Gubler’s involvement in Einstein marks an exciting new chapter in his career, demonstrating his versatility as an actor and his ability to take on diverse roles.
Honoring the Past, Embracing the Future
The recent episode of Criminal Minds: Evolution successfully honored the show’s past while embracing its future. The return of Matthew Gray Gubler, along with mentions of Aaron Hotchner and Derek Morgan, provided a sense of continuity and nostalgia for long-time fans. These moments were carefully woven into the narrative, enhancing the emotional impact of the episode and reinforcing the bonds that define the Criminal Minds family.
Erica Messer’s commitment to acknowledging the show’s history and characters is evident in her thoughtful approach to integrating the past into the present. Despite scheduling challenges and other obstacles, the creative team continues to find ways to honor the legacy of Criminal Minds and pay respect to the actors and characters who have made it a success.
As Criminal Minds: Evolution moves forward, it will undoubtedly continue to evolve and explore new storylines and character dynamics. However, the recent episode serves as a reminder that the show’s past will always be a part of its identity, and the memories of beloved characters will continue to resonate with viewers for years to come.
The blend of nostalgia and fresh narratives positions Criminal Minds: Evolution for continued success, appealing to both loyal fans and new viewers alike. The series’ ability to balance these elements ensures its enduring relevance in the ever-changing landscape of television.
“We are incredibly grateful for the support of our fans, and we are committed to delivering stories that honor the legacy of Criminal Minds,” Messer concluded. “The past will always be a part of our DNA, and we will continue to find ways to celebrate it.”
Leave a Reply