The 2025 NHL Draft has set the stage for a thrilling new chapter in the New York hockey rivalry. Matthew Schaefer, the No. 1 overall pick by the New York Islanders, and Malcolm Spence, a second-round selection by the New York Rangers, are at the heart of this emerging clash. Once teammates and roommates with the Erie Otters in the Ontario Hockey League (OHL), they are now set to become rivals in the Big Apple. This article delves into their journey, the draft, and what this rivalry means for both players and their respective teams.
Schaefer Throws Shade After Being Drafted
Matthew Schaefer didn’t waste any time stoking the flames of the New York rivalry. Shortly after the Islanders made him the top pick, Schaefer shared his competitive spirit on the NHL Draft Class podcast, saying, “I’ve heard a lot about that rivalry. I hate losing, so I’m looking forward to going and just beating them every time we play them.” His remarks immediately added fuel to the already intense Rangers-Islanders dynamic. As the number one pick, Schaefer is expected to live up to the hype and immediately contribute to the Islanders’ roster. The pressure is on for him to perform and validate the team’s high expectations.
Spence Joins the Rangers, Creating a Rivalry Between Friends
The Rangers selected Malcolm Spence in the second round, adding an intriguing layer to the rivalry. Spence and Schaefer were not only teammates but also close friends and roommates during their time with the Erie Otters. “He’s one of my closest friends and you want to have your buddies succeed, but a little awkward now with the Rangers and Islanders,” Spence commented. The Rangers’ acquisition of Spence sets the stage for numerous head-to-head matchups between the two former teammates, amplifying the intensity of the rivalry.
Spence’s Reaction to Joining the Rangers
Spence admitted that the Rangers-Islanders rivalry angle didn’t immediately click when he was drafted. It was only when answering a question about Schaefer that he realized the implications. “Honestly, the second you said it I was thinking about it,” Spence said. “It’s a little rivalry now, but I know with ‘Schaef’, we want to be competitive so it’s going to bring the best out of each other. I’m really excited for both of our careers.” His excitement underscores the personal and professional stakes involved in this budding rivalry.
Both Players Aim to Prove Themselves
Schaefer and Spence both have clear objectives as they enter their NHL careers. Schaefer aims to prove he is worthy of the No. 1 pick status, while Spence is motivated to prove the NHL teams wrong for passing on him until the Rangers selected him at No. 43. Spence, heading to the University of Michigan, plans to carry a “chip on his shoulder,” using the draft as motivation. Despite being ranked 17th on NHL Central Scouting’s final list, 17 skaters ranked lower than him were drafted earlier, fueling his determination to excel.
Spence Reunites with Former Teammate Carey Terrance
Adding another layer to Spence’s transition to the Rangers is the presence of Carey Terrance, another former Erie Otters teammate. Terrance, who was traded to the Rangers from the Anaheim Ducks, played on the same line with Spence in Erie. “That was my first thought when I put the jersey on, maybe I’ll get to play with Carey again, which is pretty cool,” Spence said, highlighting the comfort and familiarity he’ll have within the Rangers organization. The reunion with Terrance provides Spence with a support system as he navigates his early career.
Spence’s Early Taste of New York City
Spence already has a connection to New York City through his sister, Camille, who recently graduated from Pace University in Manhattan. During a visit for her graduation, Spence had the opportunity to tour the city. “We were in New York for my sister’s graduation, so we got to tour around there,” he said. “We just went around the city, walked around. It’s a pretty cool spot. Really excited to go there and be in the big NYC. It doesn’t get better than being with the Rangers. It’s New York City. You’re in front of the bright lights and for me, I thrive playing in atmospheres like that.” His enthusiasm for the city adds to his anticipation of joining the Rangers.
Looking Ahead: Development Camps and Rivalry
Both Schaefer and Spence are set to attend their respective development camps, marking the beginning of their journeys to the NHL. The proximity of Long Island and Manhattan ensures that the rivalry will continue off the ice. “We’ll definitely have some words, for sure,” Spence said, laughing, indicating the playful banter that will undoubtedly occur between the two friends-turned-rivals. The anticipation of their future matchups adds to the excitement surrounding the Rangers and Islanders.
The 2025 NHL Draft has ignited a compelling New York rivalry between Matthew Schaefer and Malcolm Spence. From teammates to competitors, their journey promises intense matchups and plenty of excitement for fans. As they prepare for their development camps and eventual NHL careers, the hockey world will be watching to see how this rivalry unfolds. The Rangers and Islanders are sure to benefit from the infusion of talent and passion that Schaefer and Spence bring to the ice. The future of New York hockey is bright, with these two young stars ready to make their mark.
Leave a Reply