SUPERMAN Said To Have “No Real Central Plot” To Speak Of – Possible SPOILERS

The upcoming James Gunn’s Superman film is generating buzz, not only for its fresh take on the iconic superhero but also for its unconventional narrative structure. Recent test screenings have sparked discussions about the film’s “episodic” feel, drawing comparisons to Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely’s acclaimed All-Star Superman. This approach, focusing on a series of heroic feats rather than a singular, overarching plot, could be a bold move for the DCU reboot. Will this gamble pay off, or will audiences crave a more traditional superhero storyline?

This article delves into the emerging details of Superman’s plot, exploring the potential inspirations from All-Star Superman and examining the reactions from early screenings. We’ll also consider the implications of this narrative choice for the future of the DCU and discuss whether a departure from the typical superhero movie formula is a risk worth taking.

Episodic Storytelling: A Dive into Superman’s Plot Structure

Initial reports suggest that Superman will adopt an “episodic” structure, reminiscent of All-Star Superman. Instead of a straightforward, linear plot, the film may present a series of self-contained challenges and adventures for the Man of Steel. This could involve Lex Luthor concocting various schemes, ranging from unleashing a kaiju to creating a black hole, all while manipulating public opinion against Superman.

According to a scooper:

“The Superman movie is very much like All-Star Superman — no real central plot, just Lex scheming in different ways to kill Superman or get him locked up. A kaiju, a black hole in the sky, a conflict between nations, a clone — he throws everything at him. He also turns the public against Superman and gets him arrested.”

While this approach deviates from the norm, it’s important to remember that compelling characters and a solid script can elevate even the simplest plot. James Gunn’s track record with the Guardians of the Galaxy films demonstrates his ability to blend action, humor, and heart, creating memorable stories even within a familiar framework.

All-Star Superman: Inspiration or Blueprint?

The comparison to All-Star Superman raises intriguing questions about the film’s tone and themes. The comic book series, written by Grant Morrison and illustrated by Frank Quitely, depicts a dying Superman confronting his mortality while performing a series of heroic acts. This premise allows for a more introspective and emotional exploration of the character.

If Superman draws heavily from All-Star Superman, audiences can expect a film that delves deeper into Superman’s motivations and relationships. The “episodic” structure could serve as a vehicle to showcase his compassion, courage, and unwavering commitment to humanity in the face of adversity. However, it remains to be seen whether the film will directly address Superman’s impending demise, as in the source material.

Breaking the Mold: The Potential Benefits of an Episodic Approach

Superhero movies have often been criticized for adhering to a predictable formula. By embracing an episodic structure, Superman has the opportunity to subvert expectations and offer a fresh perspective on the genre. This approach could allow for greater flexibility in storytelling, enabling the introduction of diverse villains, settings, and subplots without being constrained by a rigid narrative arc.

Moreover, an episodic format could be advantageous for world-building within the DCU. Each episode could introduce new characters, locations, and concepts, gradually expanding the scope of the universe and laying the groundwork for future films and television series. However, it’s crucial that these individual episodes contribute to a cohesive whole, preventing the film from feeling disjointed or lacking in purpose.

Mixed Reactions: Early Screenings Spark Debate

Test screenings for Superman have reportedly yielded “mixed reactions,” particularly regarding the film’s story structure. While some viewers may appreciate the departure from the norm, others may find the episodic format disorienting or unsatisfying. The success of this approach will ultimately depend on how effectively James Gunn balances the individual episodes with an overarching narrative theme.

It’s important to remember that test screenings are not always indicative of a film’s final reception. Audience feedback can be valuable in identifying potential weaknesses and refining the final product. However, it’s equally important for filmmakers to stay true to their vision and avoid making changes solely to appease a vocal minority.

The Cast of Characters: Familiar Faces and New Additions

Superman boasts a stellar cast, led by David Corenswet as Clark Kent/Superman and Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane. Nicholas Hoult takes on the role of Lex Luthor, while Isabel Merced, Edi Gathegi, Nathan Fillion, and Anthony Carrigan portray Hawkgirl, Mr. Terrific, Guy Gardner, and Metamorpho, respectively. The film also features Sara Sampaio as Eve Teschmacher, Pruitt Taylor Vince and Neva Howell as Ma and Pa Kent, and Milly Alcock as Supergirl.

With such a diverse ensemble of characters, Superman has the potential to explore a wide range of themes and dynamics. The dynamic between Superman and Lois Lane, the rivalry between Superman and Lex Luthor, and the introduction of new heroes like Supergirl all contribute to the richness and complexity of the film’s narrative.

James Gunn’s Vision: A Good Man in a World That Isn’t Always So Much

James Gunn has described Superman as a story about “a good man in a world that isn’t always so much.” This suggests that the film will focus on Superman’s inherent goodness and his unwavering belief in humanity, even in the face of cynicism and despair. This theme aligns with the spirit of All-Star Superman, which celebrates Superman’s virtues and his enduring legacy.

Gunn’s signature style, blending epic action with humor and heart, is evident in the updated synopsis for the movie:

“In his signature style, James Gunn takes on the original superhero in the newly imagined DC universe with a singular blend of epic action, humor and heart, delivering a Superman who’s driven by compassion and an inherent belief in the goodness of humankind.”

Whether this approach will resonate with audiences remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Superman is poised to be a bold and unconventional superhero film.

Superman’s “episodic” story structure, drawing inspiration from All-Star Superman, represents a significant departure from the typical superhero movie formula. While test screenings have yielded mixed reactions, this approach has the potential to offer a fresh perspective on the genre, allowing for greater flexibility in storytelling and world-building within the DCU. The success of this gamble will ultimately depend on how effectively James Gunn balances the individual episodes with an overarching narrative theme, creating a cohesive and compelling cinematic experience.

As audiences eagerly await the release of Superman, the film’s unconventional narrative structure promises a unique and thought-provoking exploration of the Man of Steel’s character and his place in the world. Whether this bold move will usher in a new era of superhero storytelling remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Superman is poised to be a film that sparks conversation and challenges expectations.